• Technology
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Dimsum News
  • Technology
    After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

    After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

    UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

    UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

  • Sports
    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Papers: Salah prime target for Saudi Pro League this summer

    Papers: Man Utd have £250m to spend – but Leao to turn down summer PL move

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

  • Business
    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

  • Entertainment
    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
    Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

    Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

    Russian missile hits Poland as Ukraine’s allies hold military exercise, says Tusk

    Russian missile hits Poland as Ukraine’s allies hold military exercise, says Tusk

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

No Result
View All Result
  • Technology
    After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

    After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

    UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

    UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

  • Sports
    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Papers: Salah prime target for Saudi Pro League this summer

    Papers: Man Utd have £250m to spend – but Leao to turn down summer PL move

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

  • Business
    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

  • Entertainment
    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
    Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

    Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

    Russian missile hits Poland as Ukraine’s allies hold military exercise, says Tusk

    Russian missile hits Poland as Ukraine’s allies hold military exercise, says Tusk

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

No Result
View All Result
Dimsum News Global
No Result
View All Result
Home Health

No Surprises Act shielded patients from big medical bills. Now its arbitration system may be raising costs.

in Health
0
No Surprises Act shielded patients from big medical bills. Now its arbitration system may be raising costs.
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


A law designed to protect patients from surprise medical bills succeeded in eliminating unexpected charges, but spawned a lucrative arbitration industry with providers and specialized middlemen extracting payments far above benchmark billing rates. 

The practice is ultimately driving up healthcare costs for consumers, a CBS News investigation found.

The arbitration system Congress created to settle disputes between insurers and out-of-network providers allows doctors and resolution specialists acting on their behalf to win payments many times higher than typical rates for medical services. Those costs don’t disappear: Much of the money comes from employer-sponsored health plans, meaning workers may ultimately pay through higher premiums or reduced benefits.

Under the arbitration system established by the No Surprises Act, which took effect in 2022, insurers are paying healthcare providers hundreds of dollars for routine lab tests that typically cost between $10 and $30, industry researchers told CBS News. In one instance, a plastic surgeon was awarded more than $400,000 to perform a breast reduction, a procedure the insurer said it had previously paid the doctor between $6,000 and $30,000 to perform. 

The plastic surgeon, Dr. Norman Rowe, routinely was awarded around 170 times the benchmark rates for his services under the NSA’s arbitration system, a CBS News analysis of public data shows. 

A spokesman for Dr. Rowe told CBS News that insurers had manipulated benchmark rates to lowball doctors and create “artificially low reimbursement rates.” 

“Dr. Rowe uses the widely recognized gold standard FairHealth benchmarks set by the independent nonprofit FairHealth.org using reliable and objective market data. FairHealth data is so reliable that it is incorporated into statutes and regulations around the country and serves as the official data source for many state health programs,” the spokesman added.

In addition to the typical benchmark rate arbitrators consider (known as the “qualifying payment amount,” or QPA), FairHealth provides another rate that can be used during the dispute resolution process. Medicare rates, meanwhile, may not be considered.

CBS News found that another doctor — Long Island spine surgeon Vadim Lerman — was being awarded an average of 280 times the benchmark rates in arbitration. He declined an interview, but a spokesman for Lerman said that “the suggestion that a physician is receiving ‘hundreds of times’ above benchmark rates is incorrect. No comparison should be made to the insurer’s initial offer — which can be inappropriately low for a complex surgical procedure — and the award given to the physician.”

“Baseball-style arbitration”

Insurers have, in many cases, been forced to pay high rates like those Dr. Rowe charges under the law’s so-called “baseball-style” or “pendulum” arbitration system. 

In an arbitration under the No Surprises Act, insurers and providers each propose a rate for a given service. There’s no room for negotiation, as an arbitrator must choose between one of the two parties’ suggested figures. 

Arbitrators side with providers in more than 85% of the cases, according to Leland Robbins, a product leader at Turquoise Health, a data transparency startup. Some arbitrators – officially called certified Independent Dispute Resolution, or IDR, entities – have track records of siding with providers in an even larger share of cases, according to Robbins’ group. 

He told CBS News that while patients are no longer being surprised by large medical bills, there is a catch to the new system. 

“The transaction didn’t go away. It went behind closed doors and has moved into this arbitration process when a payer and a provider can’t agree what the fair price should be,” Robbins said. “Given that 70% of these awards are being taken out of employer-sponsored health plans, consumers are going to start seeing it when it comes time for open enrollment.”

He added, “You know, employers are not able to withstand and absorb these kinds of big fees. They’re going to be probably not paying for as much of your premiums.”

Last year, 15 government-certified arbitrators earned fees per case, with 17 arbitrators designated to do this work today. Each side in the dispute — the healthcare provider and the insurer — pays into the process prior to the arbitrator making any decision.

During the first six months of 2025, insurers and providers submitted 1.2 million new disputes to the arbitration portal, while federal officials had only expected approximately 17,000 cases per year, research from the Center on Health Insurance Reforms (CHIR) at Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy shows.

However, HaloMD, a company that files cases on behalf of providers, told CBS News that the initial estimates “were objectively flawed in how they calculated expected volume.”

screenshot-2026-10-07-at-10-41-44-am.png

TeamHealth, HaloMD and Radiology Partners accounted for the most arbitration cases under the No Surprises Act.

CBS News/Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms


Collectively, arbitrators making the decisions have earned more than $2 billion in fees. None agreed to on-camera interviews with CBS News.

New Jersey House Rep. Frank Pallone, a Democrat and the lead sponsor of the No Surprises Act, blames private equity, in part, for breaking the system he helped create. 

He said just a few private equity firms – which are increasingly buying up anesthesiology, radiology and emergency room practices — are driving arbitration cases.

Pallone told CBS News that doctors should be paid the equivalent of in-network rates for the services they provide, but said “we had no choice” but to introduce the arbitration system “if we wanted to actually get rid of surprise billing.” 

“I knew it was not going to go well, but I didn’t know it was going to be this bad,” he added. 

Dispute resolution cottage industry 

The law’s arbitration provision has also created an opportunity for intermediaries to guide providers through the process and rake in profits by taking a cut of bills that are up to 1,000% above the benchmark rate for a service, CBS News found. Critics argue that such firms demand more money on providers’ behalf, leading to the large settlements that drive up everyone’s costs.

HaloMD bills itself as “the expert” in arbitration cases brought under the No Surprises Act. Founded by Texas couple Scott and Alla Laroque in 2022, the same year the No Surprises Act took effect, the company is one of the fledgling industry’s biggest players. 

Private equity firms also sometimes own both physician staffing firms and Independent Dispute Resolution entities, creating a conflict of interest and undermining the law’s fairness. HaloMD is not private equity-backed, but Halo and two other groups with investments from buyout firms collectively handled more than 75% of disputes settled in arbitration last year, according to Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms. 

According to Halo, the firm made more than $1 billion for its clients, routinely earning awards that are nine times the benchmark rates for services. Halo takes a cut of the payouts but has not disclosed the amount.

Halo chief external affairs officer Patrick Velliky told CBS News that insurance companies, not firms like his, are responsible for driving up consumer healthcare costs by either not participating in the arbitration process or submitting ludicrously low offers. 

“24% of the time, insurers lose by default. They didn’t submit an offer at all. Another 9 1/2% of the time, insurers submit an offer, like a dollar or less,” Velliky told CBS News. “So what that actually looks like, a patient goes to the E-D with a heart attack, we go to arbitration and the insurer is offering a total of $1.00.”

He also said that insurance companies are offering misleading information about the benchmark rate. “Whatever the actual median in-network rate is, it’s not what the insurer presented,” Velliky told CBS News. “They’re miscalculating it.”

A federal court sided with providers on the issue this summer, saying the benchmark rate is “artificially low,” pulled down by insurers’ $0- or $ 1-reimbursement offers to doctors. 

Proposed reforms

Pallone wants to reform the law to gut what he sees as the root of the issues arising from the No Surprises Act: arbitration. 

He plans to introduce legislation this week to eliminate the arbitration process and stipulate that providers be paid in-network rates, even if they are out-of-network. Pallone’s office also told CBS News that so-called ghost rates, which often drag the benchmark rate down, will be excluded from calculations moving forward. 

“Whether it’s the hospitals, the doctors, the nurse, they’re really trying to care for people. Of course, all of them should have a decent income so they can live,” the New Jersey lawmaker said. “But why should these outside investors be making all this money off the backs of, you know, your insurance premiums, essentially?”

Edited by

Alain Sherter and

Aimee Picchi

More from CBS News

Go deeper with The Free Press

In:



Source link

Previous Post

Ring’s smart lock can be recharged by turning a dial

Next Post

Russian strike on buses kills at least 30, say officials, as deadly attacks on Ukraine surge

Next Post
Russian strike on buses kills at least 30, say officials, as deadly attacks on Ukraine surge

Russian strike on buses kills at least 30, say officials, as deadly attacks on Ukraine surge

Stay Connected test

  • 82.8k Followers
  • 24k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Visual Narrative Exhibition Final - 2

The Filipino Artistic Legacy in Hong Kong

November 27, 2024
Jose_Rizal_and_19th_century_lady_Hong_Kong_skyline

Cultural Bridges: The Pioneering Filipino Artists Transforming Hong Kong’s Art Scene

February 13, 2026
LG announces new UltraGear evo gaming monitors with AI upscaling

LG announces new UltraGear evo gaming monitors with AI upscaling

December 29, 2025
HKVAC exhibition 01

Hong Kong to Host Groundbreaking Art Exhibition of Filipino Cultural Identity

February 13, 2026
Jose_Rizal_and_19th_century_lady_Hong_Kong_skyline

Cultural Bridges: The Pioneering Filipino Artists Transforming Hong Kong’s Art Scene

0
Visual Narrative Exhibition Final - 2

The Filipino Artistic Legacy in Hong Kong

0
HKVAC exhibition 01

Hong Kong to Host Groundbreaking Art Exhibition of Filipino Cultural Identity

0
Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

0
After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

November 21, 2026
Get Apple’s Popular Earbuds For 28% Off on Amazon

Get Apple’s Popular Earbuds For 28% Off on Amazon

November 21, 2026
Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

November 21, 2026
UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

November 20, 2026

Recent News

After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

After Jensen Huang, Anthropic’s IPO looks even stranger

November 21, 2026
Get Apple’s Popular Earbuds For 28% Off on Amazon

Get Apple’s Popular Earbuds For 28% Off on Amazon

November 21, 2026
Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

Zelensky says Crimean Bridge strikes ‘fair response’ as he meets UK’s Streeting

November 21, 2026
UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

UN court cites military Facebook posts while finding Myanmar guilty of genocide

November 20, 2026
Dimsum News

© 2025 Dimsum News.

Navigate Site

  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Technology
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World

© 2025 Dimsum News.

imunify-bot-check
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.