• Technology
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
Friday, November 20, 2026
Dimsum News
  • Technology
    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned. What happens next?

    Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned. What happens next?

    Google’s AlphaGenome 2 zooms in on the cellular roots of disease

    Google’s AlphaGenome 2 zooms in on the cellular roots of disease

  • Sports
    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Papers: Salah prime target for Saudi Pro League this summer

    Papers: Man Utd have £250m to spend – but Leao to turn down summer PL move

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

  • Business
    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

  • Entertainment
    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    Who could replace Jensen Huang as Nvidia’s chief executive?

    Who could replace Jensen Huang as Nvidia’s chief executive?

    Egyptian journalist’s retrial adjourned as UN warns of ‘assaults on press freedom’

    Egyptian journalist’s retrial adjourned as UN warns of ‘assaults on press freedom’

No Result
View All Result
  • Technology
    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The 33 best gifts for frequent travelers in 2026

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    The aliens are coming in 3 Body Problem’s first season 2 trailer

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    Robert Pattinson is Amazon’s first James Bond

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    LG’s budget-friendly B6E OLED TV is up to 50 percent off this weekend

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can’t trust AI CEOs

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    What’s really at stake in the Jensen Huang saga

    Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned. What happens next?

    Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned. What happens next?

    Google’s AlphaGenome 2 zooms in on the cellular roots of disease

    Google’s AlphaGenome 2 zooms in on the cellular roots of disease

  • Sports
    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Neville: Is Man City charges spotlight seeping into performances?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Medina stars for Man Utd, Liverpool end Anfield hoodoo, Arsenal's title hopes over?

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Women's CL draw: Arsenal to face reigning champions Barcelona

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Bowen: As long as West Ham get back to the PL, I don't care how we do it

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Massey-Ellis retires from officiating to take up new role with FA

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Infantino offers £30m incentive for FIFA members to back controversial plans

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Palace seek £55m-plus for Lacroix as talks with Chelsea begin

    Papers: Salah prime target for Saudi Pro League this summer

    Papers: Man Utd have £250m to spend – but Leao to turn down summer PL move

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

    De Zerbi proud of Spurs win but warns: 'Don't forget situation we were in'

  • Business
    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

    Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

  • Entertainment
    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Bryan Cranston in 'deep despair' after death of Breaking Bad actor

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Why Dolly Parton was loved by all ages

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama dies aged 97

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    UK cinemas consider ban on Meta glasses

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    French DJ Kavinsky dies aged 50

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Jurassic Park star Sam Neill has died

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Naomi Campbell asks for 'respect' at hearing to appeal her charity ban

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Taylor Swift makes musical history – again

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

    Jazz legend Sonny Rollins dies

  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World
    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    The seven Anthropic founders who are about to become multi-billionaires

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Palestinian woman, 72, shot dead by Israeli settlers in West Bank, health ministry says

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Gérard Depardieu drops appeal against sexual assault conviction

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    Iran targets US military base in Bahrain with drone attack

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    First catch aborted in SpaceX Starship rocket double-catch test

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    What we know about the global Microsoft outage

    Who could replace Jensen Huang as Nvidia’s chief executive?

    Who could replace Jensen Huang as Nvidia’s chief executive?

    Egyptian journalist’s retrial adjourned as UN warns of ‘assaults on press freedom’

    Egyptian journalist’s retrial adjourned as UN warns of ‘assaults on press freedom’

No Result
View All Result
Dimsum News Global
No Result
View All Result
Home Technology

Trump’s birthright citizenship ban may fail — but the administration already got too far

in Technology
0
Oregon’s National Guard lawsuit hinges on Trump’s Truth Social posts
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


On Wednesday morning, the Supreme Court heard arguments in Trump v. Barbara, a case challenging President Donald Trump’s 2025 executive order banning birthright citizenship. Justices seemed skeptical of the administration’s argument, but by taking up birthright citizenship at all, they showed how much ground nativists have gained since Trump’s first term. The 14th Amendment is quite clear: “all persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” Trump seeks to overturn this and create a new, effectively stateless American underclass, and he’s gotten alarmingly far.

Hours after being sworn back into office for his second term, Trump issued an executive order titled “Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship.” Under the order, children born to undocumented mothers — or to women in the country on non-immigrant visas — would no longer be citizens upon birth, unless the children’s fathers were citizens or permanent residents. The order’s provisions would take effect 30 days after it was issued. It was immediately challenged in court and several federal injunctions prevented its implementation, meaning birthright citizenship remains the law of the land for now.

Trump’s efforts hinge on the meaning of a specific clause: “subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” The administration contends that noncitizens and those who don’t have permanent residency are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, since they’re actually loyal to a foreign power. This interpretation would reverse not only centuries of US law but also precedent set by English common law, leaving hundreds of thousands of children without status or stateless upon birth. Karen Tumlin, the director of the Justice Action Center, called the case a “canary in the coalmine for our democracy”: if Trump can end birthright citizenship with the stroke of a pen, then no constitutional protection is safe.

All but the most conservative justices seemed unconvinced. Their questions largely focused on two landmark decisions. One was Dred Scott v. Sandford, the 1857 case in which the court decided that enslaved people were not citizens — which the 14th Amendment was ratified partly to overturn. The other was United States v. Wong Kim Ark, an 1898 case in which the court ruled that, despite the Chinese Exclusion Act, the American-born children of Chinese nationals were indeed US citizens.

After Justice Clarence Thomas asked Sauer how the citizenship clause responds to Dred Scott, Sauer acknowledged that the 1857 decision “imposed one of the worst injustices in the history of this court.” But he argued that Congress specifically ratified the 14th Amendment to grant citizenship to “newly freed slaves and their children” who, according to Sauer, had “a relationship of domicile” to the United States and no “relationship to any foreign power.”

Nineteenth-century legislators, Sauer argued, couldn’t have foreseen the problem of birth tourism. “There are 500 — 500 — birth tourism companies in the People’s Republic of China whose business is to bring people here to give birth and return to that nation,” Sauer said. The current interpretation of birthright citizenship “could not possibly have been approved by the 19th century framers of this amendment,” he said. “We’re in a new world,” he continued, “where 8 billion people are one plane ride away from having a child who’s a US citizen.”

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who was questioning Sauer, appeared unswayed. “It’s a new world,” he agreed, but “it’s the same Constitution.”

“It’s a new world,” Gorsuch said, but “it’s the same Constitution”

Chief Justice John Roberts called Sauer’s examples of existing exceptions — including children of ambassadors or enemies during a hostile invasion — “very quirky” and not necessarily comparable to“a whole class of illegal aliens who are here in the country.” Justice Elena Kagan noted that most of Sauer’s brief focused on people who are temporarily in the country on visas — but Trump’s executive order was clearly intended to restrict immigration, and the president has said so himself.

In 2019, Trump called birthright citizenship a “magnet for illegal immigration.” Last year, presidential adviser Stephen Miller said the US-born children of immigrants are just as much of a problem as the immigrants themselves. “With a lot of these immigrant groups, not only is the first generation unsuccessful,” Miller said in a Fox News interview, citing the Somali-American community, which the administration would soon target in Minneapolis, as an example. “You see persistent issues in every subsequent generation. So you see consistent high rates of welfare use, consistent high rates of criminal activity, consistent failures to assimilate.”

The administration has sought to restrict legal immigration in all its forms: it implemented a steep fee for H-1B work visas, has signaled it may end a work program for international students, and enacted a travel ban on several countries that is even affecting World Cup players. The operation is barefacedly racist. The president famously complained about “all these people from shithole countries” who migrate and expressed his desire to have “more people from Norway.” Last year, he cut the refugee resettlement cap to just 7,500 and prioritized the resettlement of white South Africans. The Department of Homeland Security has linked the “homeland” to a decidedly white vision of Manifest Destiny that, like debates about birthright citizenship, harkens back to the nineteenth century.

Experts are broadly in agreement that most justices weren’t convinced by the administration’s argument, but it’s not clear exactly how the court will rule.

If the court did hand Trump an unexpected victory, a series of grim questions would immediately come into play — starting with when the change kicks in. The order was supposed to be implemented on February 19, 2025, thirty days after Trump signed the order, and would have gone into effect if not for a number of federal injunctions. “If the court sides with Trump, it will have to decide on a date on which to begin applying the president’s interpretation of the 14th amendment,” César Cuauhtémoc García Hernández, a professor of civil rights and civil liberties at the Ohio State University College of Law, told The Verge. “Anyone born on or after that date and described in Trump’s order would be treated as a migrant rather than a U.S. citizen.”

Sauer asked the court to apply Trump’s executive order “proactively” and not retroactively, and backdating the change to 2025 would pose a number of problems, calling the citizenship of millions of children into question.

The Trump administration is trying to narrow who counts as an American while simultaneously pushing for policies that prevent noncitizens from participating in public life. The administration has tried to prohibit states from offering in-state tuition to undocumented immigrants who live there, revoked accreditation for training centers that work with noncitizen truckers, and has broadly sought to turn America into a “papers, please” country.

Trump was in the audience during Wednesday’s arguments, making him the first sitting president to attend oral arguments before the Supreme Court. His presence may have intended to intimidate skeptical justices into taking his side. Norman Wong, a direct descendant of Wong Kim Ark, was also outside the courthouse, according to the New York Times. Wong and his family embody the stakes of this case, and he had a message for the justices: “They will be shamed for history if they get this wrong.”

Follow topics and authors from this story to see more like this in your personalized homepage feed and to receive email updates.

  • Gaby Del Valle

    Gaby Del Valle

    Gaby Del Valle

    Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

    See All by Gaby Del Valle

  • Policy

    Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

    See All Policy

  • Politics

    Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

    See All Politics

  • Report

    Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed.

    See All Report



Source link

Previous Post

Republican leaders announce two-track plan to end the DHS shutdown

Next Post

Jesy Nelson celebrates plans for rollout of SMA screenings for newborn babies | UK News

Next Post
Former Little Mix singer tells Sky News how it was her mum who first noticed twins’ rare genetic condition | UK News

Jesy Nelson celebrates plans for rollout of SMA screenings for newborn babies | UK News

Stay Connected test

  • 82.8k Followers
  • 24k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Visual Narrative Exhibition Final - 2

The Filipino Artistic Legacy in Hong Kong

November 27, 2024
Jose_Rizal_and_19th_century_lady_Hong_Kong_skyline

Cultural Bridges: The Pioneering Filipino Artists Transforming Hong Kong’s Art Scene

February 13, 2026
LG announces new UltraGear evo gaming monitors with AI upscaling

LG announces new UltraGear evo gaming monitors with AI upscaling

December 29, 2025
HKVAC exhibition 01

Hong Kong to Host Groundbreaking Art Exhibition of Filipino Cultural Identity

February 13, 2026
Jose_Rizal_and_19th_century_lady_Hong_Kong_skyline

Cultural Bridges: The Pioneering Filipino Artists Transforming Hong Kong’s Art Scene

0
Visual Narrative Exhibition Final - 2

The Filipino Artistic Legacy in Hong Kong

0
HKVAC exhibition 01

Hong Kong to Host Groundbreaking Art Exhibition of Filipino Cultural Identity

0
Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

Why Hong Kong Is the Ultimate Canvas for Artists in 2025

0
ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

November 19, 2026
Women stranded by FAA ground stop buy a Ford Bronco for a 27-hour road trip

Women stranded by FAA ground stop buy a Ford Bronco for a 27-hour road trip

November 19, 2026
Trump holds historic meeting with Xi and Putin

Trump holds historic meeting with Xi and Putin

November 19, 2026
Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

November 19, 2026

Recent News

ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

ChatGPT can transcribe as you speak now with Live Dictation

November 19, 2026
Women stranded by FAA ground stop buy a Ford Bronco for a 27-hour road trip

Women stranded by FAA ground stop buy a Ford Bronco for a 27-hour road trip

November 19, 2026
Trump holds historic meeting with Xi and Putin

Trump holds historic meeting with Xi and Putin

November 19, 2026
Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

Venezuela signs military deal with US less than a year after Maduro’s removal

November 19, 2026
Dimsum News

© 2025 Dimsum News.

Navigate Site

  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Technology
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • LifeStyle
  • Fashion
    • Music
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Health
  • World

© 2025 Dimsum News.

imunify-bot-check
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.